看完了上面这些个影评,沙发我是坐不习惯的,所以我就挨墙角转载一个IMDb上的影评,我想说,影评!不是政评或史评!
放这个上来的原因很简单,就是不能苟同这电影大部分的豆瓣影评,上纲上线儿急急忙忙地把一个好的电影艺术作品给扯成了政治教育片或历史科教片,个人觉得这样去评价电影很没节操。原因有两个,第一,作为一个从没有在德国生活过或者在那个年代生活过的人,您说的那些都不叫事实,叫道听途说;第二,不要把暴力等同于XX思想或XX主义,按您这个逻辑,全世界人民费这么多时间,花这么大劲儿干情儿巩固原始社会了。废话不多说了,转一个正常看电影人的影评:
I went to see this movie without any knowledge of the RAF. I wasen't even born when the RAF was active. Still I could follow the story of the movie because, even though some figures are vague and get no introduction, the most important story lines are explained.

The movie follows the beginning, top and ending of the first RAF-members; Andreas Baader and Ulrike Meinhof in particular. The rest of the group doesen't get the big introduction Ulrike got but with so many interesting characters the film would get even longer then its 2.5 hours.

That is inmediatly the biggest problem with the film; it's length. Because of the variety of events and characters, Der Baader-Meinhof complex never gets boring, but at some point in the movie you start to get irritated by the new events. It would be more wisely if the director had chosen to make a sequel, sothat the second RAF-members get the attention they deserve.

So why 8 out of 10 stars? Simple, as an action-movie this is brilliant. The story is good and the movie doesen't tell more than it has to. The biggest achievement however is in my point of view the political statement. It doesen't make it. Der Baader-Meinhof complex tells the story of the RAF, but never approves the actions of the group, but also doesen't disapprove them. And that is a great achievement.

巴德尔和迈因霍夫集团Der Baader Meinhof Komplex(2008)

又名:The Baader Meinhof Complex

上映日期:2008-09-25片长:150分钟

主演:马蒂娜·格德克 莫里兹·布雷多 约翰娜·沃卡莱克 

导演:乌利·埃德尔 编剧:Stefan Aust/Uli Edel/Bernd Eichinger

巴德尔和迈因霍夫集团的影评