如果抛开原著不谈，我觉得比s1进步了不少，至少我很喜欢看。少的这一颗星，就少在改编上了，改编可以，但是你不能改出一些影响人物情感纽带的东西。Yennefer would sacrifice Ciri for power? Vesemir would collect Ciri’s blood for more witchers and allow Ciri to take the trial first? 这些改编都让人感觉mind-blowing，而且这样的情节似乎就只是为戏剧化而设置的，没一个可以跟人物感情发展的逻辑自洽。我的意思不是说剧情崩了，只是觉得你不能这样一边想要抓着原著不放，一边又要大刀阔斧的改编，到最后变的两不着落。看到一条我觉得很有道理的评论，顺手贴一下。

“Note that this isn't necessarily a good or a bad thing, so long as it's done well. But there has to come a point when the adaptation is so drastically different from the source material, that I start to wonder whether it's truly an adaptation, or if it's a reimagining.”